Kalita Grill: Hand-Rolled, Home-Made, Heartfelt

If you really want to understand the heart of Kalita Grill, don’t start in the dining room—start in the grocery aisles. One of the owners, Armen Madoyan, earnestly said that they grocery shop for their own food. He wants to see, smell and touch the ingredients to determine if they are worthy of his guests. He’s inspecting tomatoes the way a jeweler inspects diamonds, rejecting anything that doesn’t meet his unspoken standard. This is a man who refuses to outsource the heartbeat of his food. “I like to buy everything myself,” he told me, and you believe him instantly. 

Kalita Grill is a family story, but not in the sentimental, scripted way restaurants like to market themselves. It’s a story shaped by detours, stubbornness, and faith. Years ago, Armen packed up his life in Boulder and moved to Seattle, working alongside his wife Tanya’s uncle at his Greek restaurant. Armen left his job behind and stepped fully into kitchen life—learning not just technique, but the rhythm of the business: the rush, the stress, the relentlessness, the joy.

The plan was for the family to join him in Seattle. But kids have a way of redirecting adult plans, and theirs wanted to stay in Colorado. So they did. Giving up the dream of their own restaurant wasn’t an option. “Believing we could do it—that was the biggest challenge,” Tanya told me. Boulder’s restaurant density didn’t make things easier with over 450 restaurants at the time. But Boulder welcomed them. And now Lafayette, barely a month into housing their newest location, has practically embraced them as family. “Everyone walks in and says, ‘Welcome to Lafayette,’” Tanya said, smiling. “And you can tell they mean it. It’s beautiful.”

Greek and Armenian cooking share a lot of DNA, but the Madoyans will tell you there’s nothing more powerful than an Armenian kitchen. Food, for them, is memory and inheritance. And those memories don’t just come from the women in the family. Armen’s father still hand-rolls every dolma the restaurant serves and makes the baklava by hand. That detail lands with weight. Dolma rolling is meditative, repetitive, and deeply personal: leaf by leaf, pinch by pinch, the kind of old-world precision that can’t be taught in a YouTube video. And baklava? Forty precise layers of phyllo, butter brushed delicately between each sheet, walnuts folded in with practiced instinct, finished with a syrup recipe guarded like a family secret. When you take a bite, it tastes like time. Like intention. Like someone’s life woven into a dessert.

Their food philosophy comes from a culture where you learn by watching, then helping, then inheriting responsibility and the ladle—an honored position for the matriarch. Tables in Tanya’s childhood home were set with fine china and silver even for everyday meals. Holidays were etiquette classes disguised as feasts. “I like beautiful things,” said Tanya. “It’s important to me, since you eat with your eyes first. Everything that is plated must be beautiful.” That instinct pulses through everything at Kalita. Their soups—lentil and avgolemono—are made every morning from scratch, no shortcuts, no giant vats simmering for days. The gyro meat is sliced, marinated, and seasoned in-house. Their Greek vendors (and both Tanya and Armen emphasize this: very Greek) deliver fresh pita, olives, feta, and phyllo every week. 

But tradition alone doesn’t keep a restaurant alive in Colorado. “Americans prefer things softer,” Armen says with a light shrug. Less intense spice. More lettuce. “Greek salad doesn’t traditionally have lettuce,” he told me, and laughed. “Americans love lettuce.” Kalita strikes a delicate balance—staying loyal to its roots while meeting people where they are. It’s not compromise; it’s hospitality. 

Speaking of hospitality: Armen and Tanya don’t treat diners like customers. “These are my guests,” Tanya insisted. And she means it. On a recent Tuesday night, Armen walked around the dining room offering warm, homemade cookies to everyone—just because. As a testament to their hospitality after only a few weeks in Lafayette, they already have regulars who come in twice a week. That’s not marketing. That’s Armenian hospitality: you feed people until they feel like family, and then you feed them more.

When it was time to eat, Armen emerged from the kitchen with plate after plate, beaming with joy in sharing his passion with others. I started with the Veggie Combo Plate which was an artfully arranged sampling of all the classics—Spanikopita, veggie dolma, falafel, hummus and baba ghanoush served with warm, delicious pita. The flavors were vibrant and fresh, a testament to the care Armen puts into selecting only the most perfect ingredients. The gyro meat is rich and cooked perfectly, thinly sliced as you want it to be. Broomfield resident Andy Williams, grabbed an entire order of just the meat to go. “Snacking meat,” he called it. The lamb, chicken and pork didn’t disappoint. The Kalita fries have a sauce on them that is so good they sell it. “I could eat this on anything,” added Williams. 

But the hero—the meat dolma. The flavor of the meat reflects generations of tradition. “No two grandmas make dolma the same, and this is our family’s recipe,” said Tanya. 

“If our food told one story,” Tanya said, “it would be clean, healthy, homemade. Love and effort in every dish.”

And she’s right. Because at Kalita Grill, you don’t just taste the food—you taste the hands that rolled, chopped, sliced, marinated, layered, and fussed over it. You taste the grocery aisles, the Seattle apprenticeship, grandma’s recipes, the father still rolling dolmas, and the brave decision to start again in a town that wasn’t waiting for them but welcomed them anyway.

And yes—you absolutely taste the dolma. Which, in my case, might have been love at first bite.

Like journalism like this? Consider becoming a sustaining supporter — and get our print edition delivered to your home each month.

Democracy needs journalism more than ever. For 25 years, we’ve told the truth — your support helps us keep doing it for the next four and beyond. Administrations come and go. Our team stays, ready to lead no matter who’s in charge.